Book Review: Artificial Wisdom, by Thomas R. Weaver

Book Description

The year is 2050. In the teeth of a climate catastrophe, the world is left with a drastic solution: one global leader to steer it through the coming apocalypse.

The final two candidates are ex-US President Lockwood, and Solomon, the world’s first political artificial intelligence. As whispers of a global conspiracy emerge, investigative journalist Marcus Tully find himself at the centre of it – when Solomon’s creator turns up murdered.

Overnight, one investigation becomes two, and it’s not just the result of the election that’s at stake but the future of the species. Suddenly humanity must make an impossible choice – between salvation, or freedom.

Continue reading “Book Review: Artificial Wisdom, by Thomas R. Weaver”

Review: Fresh Start, by Johnny Wortham

Price: £20.00
Fiction: FICTION / Science Fiction /
General
Product format: Hardback
ISBN: 978-1-78758-963-6
Pages: 336 pp

Description

A ship, a gun, and a nice teal robe to find one killer on a planet of
criminals: will Qays Mendoza get the answers he is looking for?
Qays Mendoza get the answers he is looking for?

On the edges of mankind’s domain there is a penal planet called Fresh Start
where a sentence is at best exile to five generations, but more likely death
in its harsh unforgiving wastes. It is to this planet the empire sends the
worst of the worst and it is on this planet that Qays Mendoza searches for
his old captain.

The galactic empire is falling, civilization contracts. Fresh Start is
abandoned. Without oversight, the planet is wild, without guards; the
Oubliette, the supermax prison on the supermax planet, lies open, and the
Butcher of Raznak, a killer worse than the one Qays seeks, is on the loose.
With the help of a street waif called Patience, Qays seeks answers. His soul
is stained with guilt and his spirit broken by complicity. Religion did not
have the answer; duty did not explain it. Birthright and station were not
enough. His answers lie somewhere on Fresh Start.

Continue reading “Review: Fresh Start, by Johnny Wortham”

ARC Review: The Soft Touch, by Daniel Polansky

Publisher ‏ : ‎ Grimdark Magazine
Publication date ‏ : ‎ 30 Jun. 2026
Language ‏ : ‎ English
Print length ‏ : ‎ 176 pages
ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-1923459052

Book Description

Low Town is the worst slum in the Empire, where lives are sold on the penny. Once its heir apparent, Wren returns after fifteen years to a city in turmoil, the syndicates feuding and the city on the brink of rebellion. Drawn into a tangled web of intrigue and murder, Wren finds himself the pawn in a conspiracy threatening to drive the Empire to war.

But all is not as it seems. Because Wren was trained by the most brilliant crime lord that ever lived—and he’s come back to Low Town to find him.

The Soft Touch: A Low Town novella by Daniel Polansky – Grimdark Magazine


My Review

I was sent an ARC of this book after I signed up on the GdM newsletter. I haven’t read any of the author’s books before but I liked the sound of it and now I’m intrigued by the Low Town novels. Which I will not be buying because I’m being evicted and I need to stop collecting books for the foreseeable. Once I’ve found somewhere stable to live, I’ll work my way through the collection, and then I’ll buy them. Or at least the first one. I want to know more about the background to this novella.

We meet Wren as he steps off the boat and into the Low Town. He’s clearly on a mission and affecting a rather insouciant air about the whole thing. At the same time, a very important peace treaty is being negotiated. Someone is trying to stop that treaty and Wren has a job to do, preferably without getting his coat dirty. Picking up a young assistant, picking fights with various gangs, and upsetting the secret police are just the start of things. Wren is looking for his father, who is supposed to be dead.

It’s a mystery and I loved every second of it.

There will be spoilers from here. Skip two paragraphs if you don’t want to know.

Wren is a pain in the arse to all the wrong people and charming, although it’s superficial – just to get what he needs – as he takes control of the Low Town, deals with gangsters and Black House effectively, and stops a violent uprising. He’s a cynical, violent man, who really doesn’t want to be. He hates killing, although he’s able to end lives easily, and he has a secret no one else knows, a skill he uses subtly. I don’t think it’s supposed to be a surprise to the reader when he uses his magic to defeat Katarina, since all the hints are obvious, but the magic he does is small magic, building up to his easy defeat of the Academy trained mage.

What was a surprise was the conspiracy he takes apart, I wasn’t ever sure who was doing what and why Wren was involved, until it all came together in Uncle’s office in Black House. That was a marvellous reveal.

Spoilers end here.

The setting is extremely well realised. Obviously, the author has written in this world a lot, so he is familiar with it. I’m not, and that could have been difficult, but the novella doesn’t assume previous readers, and describes the city and wider world in enough detail to understand events.

The complex politics going on around the main character, how the machinations of those with power affect those without power and how people are influenced by propaganda are explored in this novella, almost incidentally to the made plot. It’s very well done.

The Low Town makes me think of an seventeenth century London, with magic. The High Line, that connects workers to the upper reaches of society reads as though someone has dropped a maglev train into a medieval city on a hill. It is a good description of what happens when you put a major road through long-established communities that then become left behind and separated.

The secret police, Black House, is very reminiscent of so many real-world organisations, with paid informants, junior officers fighting for position willing to stab each other in the eye, and a tough leader at the top. There have been so many of those, all over the world. They usually aren’t a good thing. Think of all those killed/had their lives ruined by the FBI or the Stasi on the rumour of dissent.

The main characters, other than Wren, are Geraldine, the young person who somehow becomes Wren’s assistant, and Katarina, the Black House operative that he works with. These women are intelligent, ambitious and street smart. And violent. I found them fun to read, and their motives are not clear, although Geraldine’s growing loyalty to Wren is subtle enough that the ending isn’t that surprising but there’s still some question of where she’ll jump in the final confrontation.

The perspective of the novella is generally close 3rd person present, with Wren being the POV character, but sometimes other perspectives come in, and we never see Wren’s plans or motivations, beyond finding his father, the Warden. The writing is easy to read and I could follow events fairly well. The dislocation between perspectives – jumping from Wren in one situation to Katarina in another, for example – is used well and makes sense in context, especially when Wren turns up immediately after. It’s as though he’s actually been observing events, but the reader and the observed people don’t know he’s there.

In summary, this is an accomplished novella by an experienced writer. The world is dark, gritty, and quite realistic. The title is a hint of what’s to come and when you’ve finished the novella makes total sense.

Highly recommended.

Audiobook Review: Witch Hunt, by B.D. Spargo

Series: DCI Liam Doyle Crime Thrillers
Narrator: Aubrey Parsons
Release date: 27-03-26
Language: English
Format: Unabridged Audiobook
Length: 10 hrs
Publisher: Howfen Press

Murder, witchcraft, and a race against time – welcome to Pendle Hill.

A young woman is found brutally murdered and mutilated at the foot of Pendle Hill and the local police are in no doubt who the killer is. Newly released from a psychiatric unit, Will Perkins has delusions that the victim is a witch. When DCI Liam Doyle and his team are brought in to investigate, the suspect is already in custody and the case apparently wrapped up. Except for one key detail – evidence.

Is it really possible the origins to this murder lie in Pendle’s infamous past?

Recently returned to work, DS Anna Morgan is battling her own demons. The physical wounds from her last case have healed, but the psychological trauma still haunts her. When another body turns up the investigation is blown wide open and Doyle has to face up to the horrifying possibility that he could have prevented this killing.
Can Doyle overcome his own doubts and track down the killer before they strike again? Will Morgan be able to conquer her fear before it destroys her?

Set in and around Lancashire’s legendary Pendle Hill, Witch Hunt is a gripping British crime thriller with dark humour and a nail-biting climax. This fast-paced novel, the second in the series featuring DCI Doyle and DS Morgan, will have readers on the edge of their seats.

Purchase Links

UK Links:

https://www.audible.co.uk/pd/B0GV51STB8

USA Links:

https://www.audible.com/pd/B0GV5659QN

Continue reading “Audiobook Review: Witch Hunt, by B.D. Spargo”

Review: Ignore All Previous Instructions, by Ada Hoffmann

Format: 320 pages, Paperback
Published: May 12, 2026 by Tachyon Publications
ISBN: 9781616964566 (ISBN10: 1616964561)

Book Description

A script supervisor for an AI media conglomerate is caught between her intense need for an orderly life and her deeper, darker queer desires. From the creator of the Outside trilogy, a heartfelt interplanetary epic of identity, longing, and a space pirate who smuggles inappropriate stories.

Kelli Reynolds loves creating stories more than anything in the world. But on Callisto, a generative AI company called Inspiration owns everything, including all the media, and only Inspiration determines which stories can be told.

Kelli has a rare and coveted job in which her autism is to her advantage: She precisely edits AI output into “appropriate” stories for Inspiration’s massive TV audience. Her proudest creation is the pirate Orlando—a dashing do-gooder based on stories she used to tell friends.

Reenter Kelli’s ex-boyfriend Rowan, the person Kelli based Orlando on. Back when they were teenagers, their relationship was a secret. Kelli had thought that Rowan, a trans man, was her schoolmate Em, a girl.

Rowan is tangled up in the black market after he needed to get money for gender reassignment surgery. He needs Kelli’s help with something . . . illegal. So, now Kelli has to decide: Will she risk the safe, tidy story of her life now for the world she once wished for? What would Orlando do?

Passionate, dangerous, and tender, Ignore All Previous Instructions is a sweeping, poignant novel about censorship, forbidden love, and growing up.

My Review

I’ve known about this book for a while, because I get Ada Hoffmann’s newsletter. I got a NetGalley copy in April when I made myself go back to NetGalley, but I was struggling with the ebook version. Then my pre-ordered copy arrived on Thursday, and I started reading it yesterday. I have finished it after spending all day reading, non-stop, other than to get food. Totally immersed!

Kelli is autistic, and not the easy to empathise with cute child who is scared and shy type, but the screaming meltdowns, biting, punching type. I recognise her in me. When it all gets too painful and you can’t push the feelings down anymore, then it just explodes. Also, if you or your child are having screaming meltdowns, that’s a sign of some severely unmet needs. Instead of beating yourself or your child up for it (literally or figuratively), work out what that unmet need is AND MEET IT.

You can also be both the screaming meltdowns and the shy, scared type of Autistic, we’re complex like that.

Because we’re human.

Rowan is obviously ADHD, and as a child is misunderstood and bullied by teachers even if the kids all like him. Yeah, that sounds familiar too. Rowan’s need to transition and his need for stimulation lead him into a life that might be considered criminal. He smuggles illegal media to people in the Jovian system – that’s any media made by anyone not Inspiration.

Inspiration is the mega-corp that controls everything on Callisto. Its LLM is in everything and nobody can escape it. Human creativity is cut and controlled by models that decide on the appropriate content that will keep people happy. It’s a way to turn people into mindless robots while telling them that the company is generous and loving.

Kelli has tried not following the rules and it caused a lot of pain. Kelli tried to follow the rules and was successful – one of the 10% who had an actual job on Callisto, and one she finds fulfilling. She is a script supervisor for Inspiration, going through the outlines and scripts the genAI produces for a series featuring a character Kelli has developed since she was 8. But she can’t own the work or have her name on it, because that would be ‘stealing’ from Inspiration.

After a terrible event when they were 14, Rowan and Kelli don’t speak to each other for ten years. Rowan returns, having transitioned (in a world where transition is illegal and no one talks about Queerness lest it should ‘infect’ children) and asks for a favour. Would Kelli join him on a trip to Io to meet someone who really loves the series she’s written?

Reluctantly, Kelli agrees, and takes a few precautions, because Rowan is ‘bad’ and doesn’t follow the rules. It can’t just be talking to someone. She finds things are very much not the way Rowan said they were. For a start, the person they are meeting is the daughter of a crime boss and they want her to steal from Inspiration for the girl’s sixteenth birthday.

What follows is a heist that goes remarkably well, they get what they need and no-one gets hurt.

It all goes to hell when they get back to Io, and Inspiration’s law enforcement team arrive just at the critical moment. There is violence, explosions, a mad dash to the ship. It’s all very exciting. The emotional resolution is slow to come for Kelli but she finally works things out, just a little bit, enough to realise she wants to be with Rowan again, even if it means she loses her life on Callisto.

Their story as children is told in flashback chapters where we discover that Inspiration prevents children from learning that humans come in more than two binary heterosexual varieties, and children who look for information are prevented from learning anything. Trans people ‘don’t exist’ in this world, and what two adults do in private is no one’s business, but ‘we don’t want that in public’, so lesbian and gay people are shunned and bullied, seen as an inherant threat to children. Does that sound familiar?

Some people are so certain of their righteousness they don’t care who dies so long as they can have their exclusively cis het world. When Kelli and Rowan’s friend Elaine dies by suicide at the age of 14, Kelli decides to squash her queerness down, lock it in a box, and follow the rules. Rowan decides that he’s getting out as soon as possible. He’s already started sharing ‘illegal’ media among their tiny three person queer community, and finding ways to hack or us injection prompts to bypass controls on the computers and internet (what there is of it on Callisto) in order to jail break them, so it’s just a matter of scaling up, taking media to other frightened, isolated LGBTQIA+ people across the system, and helping to form a community.

Kelli is a realistic autistic character, Rowan is realistic as an ADHDer, while their friend Elaine has some clear mental health issues that the therapy bot is not helping. Therapy bots do not help, just like robots can’t help Autistic kids with social skills. Sorry, but trying to make us neurotypical as cheaply as possible won’t work. People with mental health problems need actual therapy and neurodivergent kids need to have their needs and learning styles respected. Just fucking do that.

These are two major parts of the narrative – neurodivergence and queerness. These are important to the author – they are autistic and genderfluid – and can speak with authority from experience of growing up in a system than pathologises both. This book benefits from that knowledge and experience; in providing realistic characters and experiences that the reader can relate to, Ada Hoffmann does what Rowan tries to do in the novel – give people stories about people like them. We all need to see ourselves in stories, being ourselves honestly and openly, finding hope and community in the stories, with other readers, and in the real world.

Reading the Afterward, I found a lot of common ground with the author, and appreciated the citations for their positions. I also understand the use of stories and using fiction to help interpret the world. I am not joking when I say I learnt to be human by reading books. Made for a strange combination at times, since I’ve liked fantasy since I was 12, but also read classics like Pride and Prejudice. Unlike me, Ada Hoffmann did something with their love of storytelling and makes a bit of a living from it.

Ada Hoffmann, under their legal name, is a PhD adjunct professor at a Canadian university, who works in computer sciences. They did their PhD in ‘creative computing’ – how can computers be used in creative work, what does it mean to sat a computer programme has been creative, that sort of thing. They thought LLMs would be used by creatives playing around and generating starting points. In the last few years, they have changed their approach, and done research into how the proliferation of LLMs/genAI has affected creatives – the damage it has done to writers and artists who live precariously as it is, including having their work stolen to train the LLMs.

LLMs are just scaled up predictive text, working from statistical analysis of what the next word in a sentence could be; they do not create, nothing they produce is original, and it amplifies any biases already present in the material it scrapes for training. The ‘artwork’ it creates is derivative and frankly bloody crap in most cases, it can’t do hands or faces, and videos are obviously faked – look for juddering on moving faces.

Basically, Ada Hoffmann is something of an expert in all the things this book is about. And they know how to write a good story. What’s not to like?

I really enjoyed the realistic space craft and space flight. The idea of sitting on top of an explosive in order to get out of a planet or moon’s gravity well does not appeal, as much as I’d love to travel the stars and see what’s out there. There’s also a discussion of how long it would take to get from Jupiter to Saturn, putting these things in perspective.

The colonies are described in enough detail to give each one its own character, and they also seem to be sensible renderings of what a colony on Callisto or Ganymede would mean.

Don’t go to Io.

It’s too volcanic for a colony.

Everyone will die.

This story was gripping, I raced through it, and I needed to know what was going to happen next. The emotional arcs were realistic and the ending satisfying. Highly recommended.

Review: Brigands & Breadknives, by Travis Baldree

Format: Audible Audio
Published: November 11, 2025 by Macmillan Audio
ASIN: B0DVBCXB4V
Language: English

Description

Return to the cosy fantasy world of the #1 New York Times bestselling Legends & Lattes series with a new adventure featuring fan-favourite, foul-mouthed bookseller, Fern.

Fern has weathered the stillness and storms of a bookseller’s life for decades, but now, in the face of crippling ennui, transplants herself to the city of Thune to hang out her shingle beside a long-absent friend’s coffee shop. What could be a better pairing? Surely a charming renovation montage will cure what ails her!

If only things were so simple…

It turns out that fixing your life isn’t a one-time prospect, nor as easy as a change of scenery and a lick of paint.

A drunken and desperate night sees the rattkin waking far from home in the company of a legendary warrior surviving on inertia, an imprisoned chaos-goblin with a fondness for silverware, and an absolutely thumping hangover.

As together they fend off a rogue’s gallery of ne’er-do-wells trying to claim the bounty the goblin represents, Fern may finally reconnect with the person she actually is when there isn’t a job to get in the way.


My Review

I have multiple copies of this book and fully intend to get more. There are different editions and bindings! So far I have two different hardback editions and the audiobook. I was going to hold off reading until the paperbacks came out, but then I remembered I’d started the audiobook, so, after finishing Tales From The Territory, I started listening to the audiobook again. I needed to know what Zyll was up to. Zyll is the chaos goblin in the first short story, and she’s a main character in this book, along with Fern the bookseller from Bookshops & Bonedust, and Astryx, the elf-maiden, a famous hero of adventures in the Territory.

Fern moved to Thune as part of her midlife crisis, only to realise that she doesn’t actually want to sell books anymore. She gets rat-arsed and falls asleep in a wagon. Waking up with a nasty hangover, she realises she’s accidentally stowed away with Astryx and Zyll. Zyll is technically a prisoner, but she’s not very good at being one. She keeps escaping, then turning back up whenever she wants.

Astryx agrees to carry Fern to the nearest town so she can get a lift back to Thune. Along the way, they deal with carnivorous chickens and other bounty hunters desperate for the massive bounty on Zyll, and develop a friendship. Fern remains with the pair after sending a short and unhelpful letter to Viv, and they travel onwards. After multiple attacks, betrayals, monsters, Fern meeting an attractive rattkin who wants her to join him, Asteryx almost dying several times, meeting penitent monks, and then a showdown with an orc and her gang, the three (plus Nigel the sword and Breadly the breadknife) arrive at their destination. Zyll is surprisingly helpful at the bounty office, and that’s all I’m going to say.

I enjoyed this novel immensely, and getting to hear Travis Baldree narrate it was fun. He’s got a funny accent but he does do the voices well. Especially Nigel’s posh sword voice. Unlike some audiobooks I’ve listened to recently, he doesn’t make the female voices sound unnaturally squeaky. They are distinct for each character.

The emotional and character development in Fern and Asteryx is very satisfying to read, and to watch develop over the course of their journey. While they both return to where they started – Fern in Thune with Viv, Asteryx on the road – they are internally changed, and they don’t stay where they were.

Spoilers: Fern goes on to meet up again with her rattkin friend, write books and secretly sign them, and Asteryx starts to hang around after her missions, getting to know people.

The descriptions of the Territory they move through is quite poetic at times, Baldree is good at describing enchanting landscapes and moving scenes. He’s equally good at the emotional elements, describing Fern’s complicated feelings and difficulties. I cried, lots, when Asteryx asked Fern to ride with her, and when Fern apologised to Viv. I am emotional, sorry, I love a happy ending, especially when it’s friends finding each other.

Overall, I’m happy I got my three different editions, and this will join Legends & Lattes and Maps, Magic, & Mischief on my cosy fantasy comfort rotation.

ARC Review: Tales From The Territory. by Travis Baldree


EDITION: Other Format
ISBN: 9781035083350
PRICE: £18.99 (GBP)
PAGES: 224
Publication date: 1st October 2026 Publisher: TOR

Description

From Sunday Times bestseller Travis Baldree, Tales from the Territory is a beautiful collection of cosy fantasy tales, set in the much-loved world of Legends & Lattes.

There are many tales yet untold . . .

‘GOBLINS & GREATCOATS’:
 Chaos goblin Zyll is involved in a case of mistaken identity, where she solves a murder at an inn whilst simultaneously stealing all the cutlery.

‘JUST A THIMBLEFUL’: The sweet rattkin baker Thimble finds a new home for his soon-to-be famous cinnamon rolls.

‘PAGES TO FILL’: An act of mercy leads to a life-changing discovery for warrior orc Viv.

In ‘MIROGRAPH’, young succubus Tandri assists a university professor on a mysterious project where art and science collide.

In ‘CAVALIERS & COFFEES’, Viv, now the owner of Legends & Lattes coffee shop, discovers that imitation is not the highest form of flattery.

Featuring bespoke, full-page colour illustrations and endpapers, this is a deluxe collection of cosy short stories.

My Review

I got this one from Netgalley. I know, look at me reading ebooks again. Admittedly, it’s a collection of short stories and I read a few pages, get up, do something else, then go back to reading, but it’s something. Plus, I need to distract myself from all the eviction stress.

This is a collection of short stories featuring, for the most part, characters from Legends & Lattes in their lives before the coffee shop, and one set between the first book and Brigands & Breadknives, which I will review eventually. I’m waiting for the paperback because I don’t want to damage my special editions. The character in the first short story, Zyll, is a major character in Brigands & Breadknives. I love Zyll, she’s a delightful chaos monster.

We already know the characters, but their lives immediately before the events of L&L are only hinted at. In this collection we get to learn a bit more about them and their world. Thoroughly entertaining and colourful, the stories add depth to the world of the Territory, and the city of Thune particularly. I wish there were morse stories in this collection, maybe featuring more characters from the books and new characters?

I will definitely be getting a copy of this book, if possible, to add to my collection.

Review: The Tabby in Black, by Mandy Morton

Description

Chocks away! as our feline detectives investigate some sticky situations at the local chocolate factory in Catberry-on-the-Brink.
Up at the Manor House, the family is at war as dark secrets are uncovered in The Tabby in Black chocolate selection box.
Will Hettie and Tilly manage to reach the bottom layer before a murderer
strikes? Did Horace Catberry really choke on a Mog Nob biscuit? And will the
Goth Band Gums and Noses get to support The Travelling Whoopsies on their next tour?
Join Hettie and Tilly as they unwrap the mysteries swirling around the Catberry family in this bitter-sweet assortment of truth and lies

Continue reading “Review: The Tabby in Black, by Mandy Morton”

Review: The Feathered Tree  by Allan Frewin Jones

My Review

The publisher sent me this ARC a couple of months ago and it was on my list for June, but I’ve got a gap and I thought I’d read it now. It came with a lovely letter, a magpie feather and some beech seeds.

I made a post on Instagram last week when I had read the first 23 chapters. Here’s my summary from there:

The MC is 16 but acts younger in some ways. Immediately got Au vibes, from her and her new friend, Quinn. Tree and corvid special interests.

The writing is probably more what I’d have read at 12 rather than 16. It actually reminds me of the tone and comprehension level of the first two Song of the Lioness books but obviously not set in a secondary world or with knights and battles.

The supernatural element of the dryad and setting in the west country feels familiar but also unfamiliar, a weird, uncannyness. Could be real, could be a traumatised teenager on her summer hols daydreaming, if you see what I mean.

Easy to read, short chapters.

Bullying element is sensitively handled, and an experience I recognise. Just because they aren’t beating you up doesn’t mean they aren’t bullies. Teenage girls are absolute bitches at times and their boy ‘friends’ are nasty little cowards hoping to touch a boob if they are just unpleasant enough. Touched a nerve, sorry.

Now, having finished the book, I have more to add:

The way Polly and Quinn share their joy in their interests is really sweet, they really want to know each other and their interests, and the description is an amazing description of two autistic people sharing their special interests and being intoxicated with it and each other.

The final trick from Ashley and her friends is awful, but Quinn seeing the truth about his sister, and Nyssa and the tree-wights coming to the rescue is really engrossing.

I cried. The way Polly and Quinn celebrate planting saplings and joining the song of nature is so powerful. I couldn’t help myself, I cried so much.

This is a story for younger teenagers, but it explores things they will be interested in, like first love, dealing with family difficulties and unusual family structures, being bullied, and the transition from secondary school to Further Education. It is written in a way that would have appealed to me as a younger teenager, but these days I don’t know what twelve-year-olds are reading.

The environmental theme is strong in this book, and I can see the intention – humans have messed up, we can do better, and some people are. I can see that the author is linking folklore to modern environmental issues, but it is a little unsubtle at times. Maybe it needs to be for the intended readership age to get the message over, but it can also put them off. Kids don’t like being told what to think, it’s better to let the theme speak for itself.

Frewin Jones has done a good job of integrating the folklore elements in with the coming of age story. It’s possible that the characters could be imagining things, like Polly and her friendship with Nyssa could be a teenager going through a difficult time telling stories to make things better, but the way it’s written pulls it together so that we the reader knows that Polly is really experiencing these things.

There’s something of a romanticism of the past and folklore, which is fine, but can be slightly misleading about history. We don’t know the beliefs of people in the West Country pre-Christian conversion. There are a lot of folk stories, and the Cornish saints had some good stories, but no one knows the significance of the stone circles or the individual stones that they set up. I read a lot of Rosemary Sutcliffe etc. as a young teen, I know this stuff when I see it – it’s based on 19th and 20th century beliefs about prehistoric beliefs and lives, based on limited understanding of the archaeological evidence available at the time. See also, the green man etc. for 19th century fuckery with folk traditions and folklore. I’ll forgive it because 30 years ago I wouldn’t have known that. I’ve read a lot of mythology and folklore because I read books where the author wasn’t quite correct. Go forth children and read all the archaeology, history, mythology, and folklore!

I enjoyed this story. It was well-written, pitched well for the target audience and sensitively deals with difficult topics. Some of the Devon dialect from the elderly neighbour was fun; my gran is an old lady from Devon but she doesn’t use a lot of dialect anymore, which is a shame.

Also, visit Devon, it’s amazing!

Netgalley Audiobook Review: Hoax, by Madeleine Pelling

Version 1.0.0

Description

Here lies Fanny Lynes, whose whispers from beyond the grave set London alight with scandal.
Here swings Mary Bateman, who lived a life of lies – and died a prophetess and murderer.
Here stands Mary Willcocks. Or is it Anne Burgess? Or Princess Caraboo, from the distant island of Javasu?

A ghost. A witch. A princess. This is a story of those who lie. And of those who choose to believe them.
The discoveries of the Enlightenment unsettled as much as they excited. New truths challenged longstanding beliefs. Rationalism jarred with superstition. Which voices would be heard in this ferocious battle for certainty?

From the chaos, three women and their hoaxes rose as symbols of terror and fascination. But were the lies surrounding Fanny Lynes, Mary Bateman and Mary Willcocks entirely of their own making? Why were the public transfixed?

Questioning culpability and complicity, Pelling’s engrossing history of this great age of the hoax reveals a veiled world of moral panic, tall tales and true crime, and holds a mirror to our own turbulent relationship with truth.


My Review

Maddie Pelling is one of my favourite podcasters and I really enjoyed her previous book ‘The Writing on the Wall’ so I was excited to listen to Hoax. The author has a good voice for narration, she speaks steadily and the narrative flows well. The book is about three famous 18th century hoaxers and it puts each person in the context of their time and place, follows their lives and the effects their actions have on society and the people around them.

I hadn’t heard of any of these individuals and found their stories fascinating. The particular circumstances of each shows certain aspects of their society and times in a century of advancing change, and the influence the media of the day had on the spread of the hoaxes. I found this an enjoyable and informative listen.